Sunday, August 28, 2011

Article Review: "Encouraging the Digital Economy and Digital Citizenship"


Missingham, R. (2009). Encouraging the Digital Economy and Digital Citizenship. Australian Library Journal, 58 (4), pp 386-399


Roxanne Missingham is Parliamentary Librarian, Australian Parliamentary Library, and is responsible for the delivery of research and information services to the Commonwealth Parliament. She has had a long career in libraries and IT, focused on the development of digital delivery and digital services. A current fellow and former president of ALIA, she is convenor of Electronic Resources Australia and the ALIA Advisory Committee on Public Sector Information.


Missingham is interested in the way that the Australian Government acknowledges the need for Australians to have: a) access to high speed Internet and b) quality, relevant content, in order to be active informed citizens that can participate in government and the economy via the digital environment. The article states that there are many benefits to being digital literate, and our aim should be universal access for all Australians. Yet, there are challenges that need to be addressed if the aim of universal access is achieved. Missingham identifies three major issues that need to be overcome: connectivity, content and capacity.


The main barrier to connectivity is access to high speed broadband for all Australians, not just those in metropolitan areas. Missingham provides examples of rural Australians frustrated by the disparities in Internet speed compared to the cities, and shows how they are disadvantaged ­­­– using real examples such as PDFs and videos not being able to be downloaded because they time out and lose connection. Missingham states that the Governments commitment to the introduction of the National Broadband Network (NBN) will enable to the majority of the population to overcome this barrier.


Access to reliable content is also of major importance, a view that led the Government, in conjunction with the National Library of Australia, to establish Electronic Resources Australia (ERA). ERA is a national site that provides access to key quality databases, chosen by a number of different library institutions from around Australia.


The third issue highlighted by Missingham is capacity – all Australians need to have the skills to be able to effectively use the Internet and available digital resources. Missingham states that this should be achieved by Public Libraries through the provision of training, support and access to digital content. Services need to be user-focused and easy to use, and digital services need to be accessible to those with disabilities.


The strengths of this article are that it is a thorough, authoritative and current argument addressing the real need for all Australian citizens to have the access and ability to high speed Internet. It has been well documented in other literature the benefits of being digitally literate and the importance of being an information society. (Karvalics, 2007; Servon, 2002; Wielm, 2004) The author has excellent credentials with years of experience, which give weight and validity to her arguments.


The weakness of this article, however, is that while Missingham does provide persuasive examples and arguments in favour of Australians having universal access to high speed Internet and the ability to use it, she ignores many other challenges that need to be overcome in order to achieve universal access.


There have been many articles written on the concept of the 'digital divide'. The digital divide separates those who are connected to the digital revolution in ICTs and those who have no access to the benefits of the new technologies. (WSIS, 2011) This happens across international frontiers as well as within communities where people are separated by socio-economic and knowledge barriers. (WSIS, 2011) The term does not only refer to those who do not have access to computer hardware, but inequalities between groups of people in their ability to use information technology fully. (Wielm, 2004)


Missingham does not mention the concept of the digital divide or include these factors, instead offering a simplistic view that Internet speed and good resources are all Australians need to become digital literate. Further analysis of the digital divide concept shows that other factors contributing to being left behind are age, gender, ethnicity, language barriers, socio-economic factors and employment divides. (Bennett, Maton & Kervin, 2008; Black & Atkinson, 2007; West, 2011; Mossberger, Tolbert & Stansbury, 2003)


This is a strong article written by an acknowledged Australian expert. Missingham's central argument – that Australians need to be digital literate and have good access to high-speed Internet and good resources is true, timely and important. Thought provoking examples are given to underscore the arguments, however, further analysis on the concept and causes of the digital divide would have given her points more weight.


REFERENCES

  • Bennett, S., Maton, K. & Kervin, L. (2008). The 'Digital Natives' debate: A critical review of the evidence. British Journal of Educational Technology. Vol. 39, Issue 5, pp. 775-786.
  • Black, R. & Atkinson, J. (2007). Addressing the Digital Divide in Rural Australia. AUSWEB 2007 Conference Proceedings. Southern Cross University: Lismore, NSW. Accessed online 8/8/11 from: http://ausweb.scu.edu.au/aw07/papers/refereed/black/paper.html
  • Karvalics, L. (2007) Information Society – what is it exactly? (The meaning, history and conceptual framework of an expression). Accessed online 8/8/11 from: http://www.ittk.hu/netis/doc/ISCB_eng/02_ZKL_final.pdf
  • Mossberger, K., Tolbert, C. & Stansbury, M. (2003). Virtual Inequality: Beyond the Digital Divide. Georgetown University Press: Washington DC.
  • Servon, L. (2002). Bridging the Digital Divide: Technology, Community and Public Policy. Blackwell: Malden, MA.
  • West, J. (2011). Without a Net: Librarians Bridging the Digital Divide. Libraries Unlimited: Santa Barbara, CA
  • Wielm, A. (2004). Digital Nation: Towards an Inclusive Information Society. MIT Press: Cambridge MA.
  • WSIS. (2011). World Summit of the Information Society Geneva 2003–Tunis 2005. 'Basic Information: Frequently Asked Questions' Accessed online 8/8/11 from: http://www.itu.int/wsis/basic/faqs_answer.asp

Article Review: "Documenting the Global Conversation: Relevancy of Libraries in a Digital World"


Heath, F. (2009). 'Documenting the Global Conversation: Relevancy of Libraries in a Digital World'. Journal of Library Administration, 49:5, pp 519-532.


Fred Heath is the vice provost and director of the University of Texas Libraries. No further information about his credentials or previous published works are given in this article, but according to the University of Texas Libraries he has over 30 years experience in academic libraries as a librarian and library director, serves on numerous library boards, and makes frequent presentations and publishers in the area of digital library trends. (University of Texas Libraries, 2011)


In this article Heath explores the impact information and communication technologies (ICTs) are having on research libraries and the challenges these libraries face in order to survive and remain relevant. Noting the widely held view that in the digital age libraries are at risk of becoming obsolete and irrelevant, Heath goes on to compare Libraries with what he calls "our sister professions", namely newspapers, the music industry, book publishing and higher education, industries that are also experiencing relevancy and survival issues.


Heath identifies survival strategies that these other professions have utilised in order to combat the challenges ICTs bring, and suggests that for research libraries to survive and stay relevant, they must: embrace ICTs; continue doing the things they do best (by providing good accurate information in a timely manner); ensure that graduating librarians are well trained in new ICT developments; rethink the role of the reference desk within the library; rethink book storage, collection building and resource sharing with other libraries to enable the buildings to be used as an interactive meeting space; acquire specialist distinctive resources; and provide access to search tools and resources on the internet beyond the library's collections.


This article is strong in acknowledging that continuing developments in ICTs risk making libraries redundant and obsolete, yet, there is hope for the future if libraries choose to embrace this technology and change with the times. There have been numerous publications reporting that many people fear libraries are no longer relevant in a digital age where access to information is readily available. (Rowlands et al, 2008; Bennett, Maton & Kervin, 2008; Buckley Owen, 2007) There have also been many articles that support the theory that the best way for the industry to face these challenges is to embrace the technology and utilise their many benefits. (Servon, 2002; Wielm, 2004; Sherman, 2011)


It is interesting that Heath compares research libraries with other professions facing similar challenges, and looks to strategies these professions are undertaking to combat them. Heath also makes good use of his extensive experience in academic libraries by giving a considered insight into the strategies that the University of Texas are implementing in order to stay relevant.


This, however, leads into the article's weaknesses. The title of the article suggests that Heath is concerned with the relevancy of libraries in a digital world, however, he only focuses about his own University Library. There is no mention of public and other libraries facing the same challenges. Many of these organisations would not have the budget or the resources of the University of Texas Libraries. For the article to carry more weight, it would have been appropriate to include studies of other libraries strategies. The strategies for survival that the University is undertaking are strategies that have been offered in numerous other articles (Casey & Savastinuk, 2006; Courtney, 2007; Dority, 2006; Lachance, 2009) and do not really offer any new ideas.


In conclusion, Heath's main point is accurate – that for libraries to remain relevant in a digital world they must embrace, utilise and master the technology. However, by focusing on the University of Texas Libraries the author fails to live up to his title by only referencing a well resourced, specialised University Library. I would not necessarily recommend this article to students of the topic. I would instead direct students to seek out broader investigations into the issue of relevancy in a digital world.


REFERENCES

Article Review: "All That Glisters Is Not Gold: Web 2.0 and the Librarian"


Anderson , P. (2007). All That Glisters Is Not Gold: Web 2.0 And The Librarian. Journal of Librarianship and Information Science, 39(4), 195+.


Paul Anderson is a technology writer and Technical Editor of JISC Technology & Standards Watch. He is a graduate of Leeds University (computer science) and has over 20 years of experience working in computing in both academia and industry.


Paul Anderson provides a discussion in this article about the effects Web 2.0 and social media applications are having within the library community under the moniker of 'Library 2.0'. He is interested in the need to develop more formal definitions and frameworks. Noting that the Internet has become an integral part of our everyday lives, Anderson highlights the importance of librarians incorporating this technology into their profession, and the need to be aware and up to date with all developments in this constantly changing and expanding area of information access and delivery.


Web 2.0 is a catch-all term describing Information and Communication Technology (ICT) applications that facilitate a more socially connected Web where anyone can create and edit information, such as blogs, wikis and social networking sites like Facebook and MySpace. (O'Reilly, 2005) Library 2.0 is a loosely defined model, which incorporates the key principles of Web 2.0 and applies them to a library context. Library 2.0 was first coined by Michael Casey on his blog LibraryCrunch in 2005. (Casey, 2005)


Anderson briefly outlines the history of Web 2.0; a proposed framework for analysis of Library 2.0; and looks at the impact Web 2.0 has had on libraries. The article highlights the fact that there is little theoretical, peer-reviewed work that analyses Library 2.0, and that some of the challenges facing Library 2.0 include limitations in terms of respect for privacy and copyright. It also states, however, that Library 2.0 is an exciting tool for libraries to stay relevant and be able to connect to their users and expand their services in ways previously unimagined.


As a useful introduction to the principles of Web 2.0 and Library 2.0, Anderson has written a strong piece. His article offers a concise summary of Web 2.0 history, its relevance within the library context, and potential advantages for future development and benefits for libraries. This is particularly the case given that the article was written in 2007, only a few years after the capabilities of the technologies were starting to be realised. When put into the context of books and articles written on Library 2.0 since then, the key points outlined by this article are still valid. (Evans, 2009; Savard, 2011; Parkes & Hart, 2010)


This highlights the contribution this article has had in the understanding Library 2.0, which can be further demonstrated by its many citations in other articles further exploring Library 2.0 (Al Daihani, 2009; Tajer, 2009; Mavodza, 2010) Paul Anderson is a respected, award-winning technology writer with years of experience, which provides a solid basis for his opinions and analysis. Further, the article was published in the Journal of Librarianship and Information Science, which is a trusted and reliable source.


The strength of this article as an introductory tool also indicates the limitation of the piece. This article was written in 2007 when there had been little theoretical work acknowledging Library 2.0, and there weren't any formal definitions or frameworks for rationalising the implications of Web 2.0 and Library 2.0 services. This is very much an introductory article, one designed to encourage further discussions and research on the subject.


There are no real examples of how librarians and library services use Library 2.0 on a day-to-day basis. The author is a technology expert, not a librarian or information professional, and is, therefore, more concerned with explaining technical concepts, while encouraging other information professionals to engage with the issues further themselves.


Anderson's clever use of the Shakespeare quote "All that glisters is not gold", implies that while this new technology offers endless possibilities, there are some concerning issues that information professionals must address head on, namely privacy and copyright issues. However, in the intervening years there have been developments in raising user awareness of what they need to do to protect privacy and copyright. (Drushel & German, 2011) Anderson's position, that the positives outweigh the negatives, has so far been proven to be correct.


Interestingly, Anderson does not look at other issues concerning Library 2.0, like accessibility and those who may be left behind. I believe that this is symptomatic of a general sidelining of accessibility issues across the Internet as a whole. Anderson's expertise is in the practical use of software, not the human implications and consequences of using (or not using or fully utilising) the technology.


Overall, this is an excellent introductory article on Library 2.0 from a trusted reliable source. I would recommend the article as a starting point for studying Web 2.0 and Library 2.0.



REFERENCES

  • Al Daihani, S. (2009). The Knowledge of Web 2.0 by Library and Information Science Academics. Education for Information, Vol 29 No 1, pp 39-55.
  • Casey, M. (2005). Working Towards a Definition of Library 2.0. LibraryCrunch. Accessed online 8/8/2011 from: http://www.librarycrunch.com/2005/10/working_towards_a_definition_o.html
  • Drushel, B.E. & German, K. (2011). Ethics of Emerging Media: Information, Social Norms, and New Media Technology. Continuum: London, UK.
  • Evans, W. (2009). Building Library 3.0: Issues in Creating a Culture of Participation. Chandos Publishing: Oxford, UK.
  • Mavodza, J. (2010). Knowledge management practices and the role of an academic library in a changing information environment: the case of the Metropolitan college of the New York. UNISA Institutional Repository. Accessed online 8/8/11 from: http://uir.unisa.ac.za/handle/10500/3945
  • O'Reilly, T. (2005). What is web 2.0? Design Patterns and Business Models for the Next Generation of Software. O'Reilly Media. Accessed online 8/8/2011 from: http://oreilly.com/web2/archive/what-is-web-20.html
  • Parkes, D. & Hart, L. (2010). Libraries: Impacts, Technologies and Trends. Chandos Publishing: Oxford, UK.
  • Savard, R. (2011). Marketing Libraries in a Web 2.0 World. De Gruyter: Berlin, Germany.
  • Tajer, P. (2009). Reference Services 2.0: A Proposal Model for Reference Services inLibrary 2.0. INFLIBNET's Institutional Repository. Accessed online 8/8/11 from: http://ir.inflibnet.ac.in/dxml/handle/1944/1041



Watch Library 2.0 Manifesto Video