Sunday, August 28, 2011

Article Review: "Documenting the Global Conversation: Relevancy of Libraries in a Digital World"


Heath, F. (2009). 'Documenting the Global Conversation: Relevancy of Libraries in a Digital World'. Journal of Library Administration, 49:5, pp 519-532.


Fred Heath is the vice provost and director of the University of Texas Libraries. No further information about his credentials or previous published works are given in this article, but according to the University of Texas Libraries he has over 30 years experience in academic libraries as a librarian and library director, serves on numerous library boards, and makes frequent presentations and publishers in the area of digital library trends. (University of Texas Libraries, 2011)


In this article Heath explores the impact information and communication technologies (ICTs) are having on research libraries and the challenges these libraries face in order to survive and remain relevant. Noting the widely held view that in the digital age libraries are at risk of becoming obsolete and irrelevant, Heath goes on to compare Libraries with what he calls "our sister professions", namely newspapers, the music industry, book publishing and higher education, industries that are also experiencing relevancy and survival issues.


Heath identifies survival strategies that these other professions have utilised in order to combat the challenges ICTs bring, and suggests that for research libraries to survive and stay relevant, they must: embrace ICTs; continue doing the things they do best (by providing good accurate information in a timely manner); ensure that graduating librarians are well trained in new ICT developments; rethink the role of the reference desk within the library; rethink book storage, collection building and resource sharing with other libraries to enable the buildings to be used as an interactive meeting space; acquire specialist distinctive resources; and provide access to search tools and resources on the internet beyond the library's collections.


This article is strong in acknowledging that continuing developments in ICTs risk making libraries redundant and obsolete, yet, there is hope for the future if libraries choose to embrace this technology and change with the times. There have been numerous publications reporting that many people fear libraries are no longer relevant in a digital age where access to information is readily available. (Rowlands et al, 2008; Bennett, Maton & Kervin, 2008; Buckley Owen, 2007) There have also been many articles that support the theory that the best way for the industry to face these challenges is to embrace the technology and utilise their many benefits. (Servon, 2002; Wielm, 2004; Sherman, 2011)


It is interesting that Heath compares research libraries with other professions facing similar challenges, and looks to strategies these professions are undertaking to combat them. Heath also makes good use of his extensive experience in academic libraries by giving a considered insight into the strategies that the University of Texas are implementing in order to stay relevant.


This, however, leads into the article's weaknesses. The title of the article suggests that Heath is concerned with the relevancy of libraries in a digital world, however, he only focuses about his own University Library. There is no mention of public and other libraries facing the same challenges. Many of these organisations would not have the budget or the resources of the University of Texas Libraries. For the article to carry more weight, it would have been appropriate to include studies of other libraries strategies. The strategies for survival that the University is undertaking are strategies that have been offered in numerous other articles (Casey & Savastinuk, 2006; Courtney, 2007; Dority, 2006; Lachance, 2009) and do not really offer any new ideas.


In conclusion, Heath's main point is accurate – that for libraries to remain relevant in a digital world they must embrace, utilise and master the technology. However, by focusing on the University of Texas Libraries the author fails to live up to his title by only referencing a well resourced, specialised University Library. I would not necessarily recommend this article to students of the topic. I would instead direct students to seek out broader investigations into the issue of relevancy in a digital world.


REFERENCES

No comments:

Post a Comment